Minimum quantity Discount
Buy 2 + Get 10% discount
Skip to content
About Us Blog Gotham Quilts Community

Mystery Five-0

A Story Driven Mystery Quilt Along

Mystery Five-0 is Gotham Quilts' collab with sister shop, Tiny Apple Fabric and Crafts. It's an interactive mystery quilt along where every clue advances both your quilt and a fun, ongoing story. Choose your pace and project size with either a quarterly throw size mystery or a faster, one day, mini-mystery. Both are beginner friendly yet satisfying for seasoned quilters.

Each clue delivers clear, step-by-step instructions, skill building tips, and helpful videos so you can sew with confidence. Join with our curated kits or shop your stash, then enjoy community sharing, weekly reveals, and a beautiful and fun finished project you'll be proud to show off.

Filters

$
$
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Black White and Green All Over

    2 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Purple Batik

    8 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Warm Batiks

    5 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Tim Holtz Flowers

    6 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Tula Flowers

    2 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00
    $150.00 - $150.00
    $150.00

    Mystery Five-0 - Surf's Up - Kit - Wisteria

    1 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95

    Pattern: Mystery Five-0 Luau Torches

    7 available

    Bring a radiant, timeless glow to your home with the Luau Torches Quilt Pattern. This design pairs rich colors with a classic layout to create a so...

    View full details
  • $130.00 - $130.00
    $130.00
    $130.00 - $130.00
    $130.00

    Mystery Five-0 Luau Kit - Enrapture

    1 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95

    Pattern: Mystery Five-0 Luau Feast

    4 available

    Bring the spirit of celebration to your sewing room with the Luau Feast Quilt Pattern. This dynamic design uses bold blocks and flowing movement to...

    View full details
  • $153.95 - $153.95
    $153.95
    $153.95 - $153.95
    $153.95

    Kit: Mystery Five-0 Island Hopping Independence Day

    3 available

    Set sail on a new adventure with Mystery Five-0! Beginning November 5th, our second quarterly mystery, Island Hopping, invites you to piece togethe...

    View full details
  • $153.95 - $153.95
    $153.95
    $153.95 - $153.95
    $153.95

    Kit: Mystery Five-0 Island Hopping International Day of Peace

    2 available

    Set sail on a new adventure with Mystery Five-0! Beginning November 5th, our second quarterly mystery, Island Hopping, invites you to piece togethe...

    View full details
  • $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00

    Kit: M50 Starry Night | Kaffe Garden Party (Pattern Included)

    3 available

    Hand selected 6 coordinating fat quarters (18" x 22") for the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along #3 Starry night. -Finish size 21" x 21"-In...

    View full details
  • $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00

    Kit: M50 Starry Night | Kaffe Floral Burst (Pattern Included)

    1 available

    Hand selected 6 coordinating fat quarters (18" x 22") for the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along #3 Starry night. -Finish size 21" x 21"-In...

    View full details
  • $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00

    Kit: M50 Starry Night | Quilt MN (Pattern Included)

    4 available

    Hand selected 6 coordinating fat quarters (18" x 22") for the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along #3 Starry night. -Finish size 21" x 21"-In...

    View full details
  • $130.00 - $130.00
    $130.00
    $130.00 - $130.00
    $130.00

    Mystery Five-0 Luau Kit - Moda Posh

    1 available

    Get ready to stitch your way through a story! Our Mystery Five-0 Quilt Kit is your all-in-one ticket to a thrilling quilt-along adventure. Each kit...

    View full details
  • $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    $21.00

    Kit: M50 Starry Night | Pop That Color (Pattern Included)

    1 available

    Hand selected 6 coordinating fat quarters (18" x 22") for the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along #3 Starry night. -Finish size 21" x 21"-In...

    View full details
  • $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00

    Kit: M50 Lucky Break | Clover and Dot

    2 available

    Includes 6 quarter yard cuts (9" x width of fabric). We selected these for the Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along - Lucky Break

  •
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95

    Pattern: Mystery Five-0 Mini Mystery #2 - Starlight

    4 available

    This is the pattern for #2 of the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew alongs. You need just 6 fat quarters for this pattern. Finished size: 21"...

    View full details
  • $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00

    Kit: M50 Lucky Break | Palette Indigo

    3 available

    Includes 6 quarter yard cuts (9" x width of fabric). We selected these for the Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along - Lucky Break

  •
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95

    Pattern: Mystery Five-0 Mini Mystery #3 - Starry Night

    7 available

    This is the pattern for #3 of the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew alongs. You need just 6 fat quarters for this pattern. Finished size: 21"...

    View full details
  • $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    $24.00

    Kit: M50 Lucky Break | Geometry

    3 available

    Includes 6 quarter yard cuts (9" x width of fabric). We selected these for the Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew along - Lucky Break

  •
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95
    $10.95 - $10.95
    $10.95

    Pattern: Mystery Five-0 Mini Mystery #1 - Star Bright

    4 available

    This is the pattern for #1 of the 2025 Mystery Five-0 mini mystery sew alongs. You need just 6 fat quarters for this pattern. Finished size: 21"...

    View full details